Most business owners spend a great deal of time thinking about how to grow their company. Far fewer spend time thinking about what happens when an owner leaves, whether by choice, disability, divorce, or death. A buy-sell agreement is one of the most important documents a multi-owner business can have, and one of the most commonly overlooked.
What Is a Buy-Sell Agreement?
A buy-sell agreement is a contract among business owners (or between owners and the entity itself) that governs what happens to an owner’s interest when a “triggering event” occurs. Common triggers include:
- Death of an owner
- Permanent disability
- Divorce
- Retirement
- Voluntary departure or resignation
- Bankruptcy of an owner
- A dispute that leads one owner to want out
Without a buy-sell agreement in place, these events can leave a business in limbo. A deceased owner’s shares might pass to a surviving spouse who has no interest in or knowledge of the business. A divorcing owner’s spouse might claim an ownership interest in the company as part of the marital estate. A disgruntled minority owner might be stuck as a partner indefinitely, with no clear path to exit.
Key Provisions Worth Understanding
Valuation method. How will the departing owner’s interest be valued? Options include a fixed price updated periodically, a formula based on revenue or earnings, or an independent appraisal at the time of the triggering event. Ambiguity here is one of the most common sources of later disputes.
Funding mechanism. If a buyout is triggered by death or disability, how will the company or remaining owners actually pay for it? Life insurance funding buy-sell agreements are common precisely because they solve the “we owe a lot of money we don’t have” problem.
Right of first refusal vs. mandatory buyout. Some agreements require a mandatory purchase upon a triggering event; others simply give the company or remaining owners the right, but not the obligation, to buy before an owner can sell to an outside party.
Transfer restrictions. Buy-sell agreements typically restrict an owner’s ability to sell or transfer their interest to third parties without first offering it to the company or other owners, preserving the existing ownership group’s control over who joins it.
Why Legal Counsel Matters Here
A buy-sell agreement touches corporate law, tax law, and often family law all at once. The valuation and funding mechanisms have real tax consequences depending on how the agreement is structured (entity purchase vs. cross-purchase, for instance). And because these agreements are meant to apply years or decades after they’re signed, often after relationships between the parties have changed, precision in the drafting matters enormously.
It’s also an agreement best negotiated when everyone is getting along. Once a triggering event is imminent, or already happened, the incentives of the parties diverge sharply, and it’s much harder to reach an agreement that feels fair to everyone.
Client Scenarios We Commonly See
- Two co-founders start a business with a handshake and no written agreement; five years later, one wants to leave and there’s no formula for what their share is worth.
- An owner passes away unexpectedly, and their spouse, now a co-owner by inheritance, has different goals for the business than the surviving partners.
- A minority owner going through a divorce discovers that, absent a transfer restriction, their spouse may have a claim to part of their ownership interest.
- A growing company brings on a new investor and needs to update an outdated buy-sell agreement that no longer reflects the current ownership structure or company value.
Put an Agreement in Place Before You Need One
If your business doesn’t have a buy-sell agreement, or if the one you have hasn’t been reviewed in years, now is the time to address it, while all owners are aligned and can negotiate calmly. Alsaka Law & Counsel, PLLC helps Tampa Bay business owners draft, review, and update buy-sell agreements tailored to their ownership structure and goals. Reach out to schedule a conversation.
This blog post is provided for general informational purposes only and does not constitute legal advice. Buy-sell agreements involve complex tax and valuation considerations specific to each business, and the information above should not be relied upon as a substitute for consultation with a licensed attorney or tax advisor. No attorney-client relationship is formed by reading this post. For advice regarding your particular situation, please contact Alsaka Law & Counsel, PLLC directly.
Tampa Attorney, Tampa Lawyer, Tampa Bay Law Firm, St. Pete Law Firm, Business Law, Brandon Law, Corporate Counsel, Tampa Fractional Counsel